Jump to content
Sactown Plumbing Guide

Explainer ยท Sacramento

Cost of an on demand water heater

An on demand water heater costs more to install than a tank but heats only when you open a tap. This guide covers tank-to-tankless conversion, gas versus electric running costs and the 50-gallon comparison.

A compact wall-mounted tankless water heater in a garage

This Old House's water heater cost guide (updated June 2026) puts an on demand water heater at $2,100 to $4,000 installed, with an average of about $2,800. An on demand unit is the same thing as a tankless water heater. It heats water as it flows, so there is no tank to keep hot. The unit is only part of the price. Gas piping, venting and electrical work add to it. Sacramento prices vary.

This guide looks at conversion and running costs. For how the install works and who does it, see the main page on tankless water heater installation.

What does cost of an on demand water heater mean for your home?

It means two bills: the install now and the energy later. Fixr's 40-gallon water heater guide (updated January 2026) lists $1,000 to $4,000 to convert from a tank to tankless. The extra comes from work the house was never built for, such as a bigger gas line or a new vent.

Here is how the pieces add up for a gas conversion:

ItemTypical cost
Tankless unit, whole house$450 to $1,500 (Fixr)
Larger gas line (if needed)Up to $800 (Fixr)
Labor, 4 to 8 hours$800 to $1,500 (This Old House)
Permit$50 to $200 (This Old House)
Removal of the old tank$50 to $150 (Fixr)

These are guide ranges from This Old House's water heater cost guide (updated June 2026) and Fixr's tankless guide (updated January 2025). The plumber you hire quotes the actual price after seeing your gas meter, your wall and the room.

How much does a tank to tankless conversion cost?

Converting a tank water heater to tankless costs $1,000 to $4,000 according to Fixr's 40-gallon water heater guide. The conversion is expensive because a tank and a tankless heater have different needs. A tank burns gas slowly. A tankless unit burns a lot at once, so it needs a bigger line and a different vent.

A garage with an old tank heater beside a bare wall ready for a tankless unit

Typical add-on work for a conversion:

  • Gas line upsizing. A line that fed a 40,000 BTU tank may need to feed a 150,000 to 199,000 BTU tankless unit. The meter may also need to be checked with the utility.
  • New venting. Tank heaters often use an atmospheric flue, a single metal pipe through the roof. Tankless units usually need sealed vent pipe, often through a side wall.
  • Electric supply. Even gas tankless units need a standard outlet for the fan and controls, and an electric tankless model needs a heavy circuit.
  • Wall mounting. A tankless heater hangs on a wall. A tank sits on the floor, so the plumber re-plumbs the hot and cold lines.

Plumbing and gas work must be done by a contractor holding a California license when the job is $1,000 or more or needs a permit, and a conversion meets both tests. Be wary of anyone who says no permit is needed.

How much does natural gas tankless installation cost compared with electric?

Fixr's tankless guide (updated January 2025) lists $1,400 to $3,500 for a gas tankless installation and $1,000 to $3,000 for an electric one, unit plus labor. Electric units are cheaper to install when the panel has spare capacity, because they need no vent or gas line. A panel upgrade can erase the saving.

An electric tankless heater for a whole house can draw 100 to 150 amps at once, divided across two or three circuits. Many older Sacramento homes have a 100-amp or 125-amp main panel, and that cannot carry a whole-house electric tankless unit plus the rest of the house. That is why a gas unit is more common here for whole-house use. A small electric unit under a single sink is a different case.

Gas versus electric tankless water heater: what is the monthly cost?

For most households, a gas tankless heater costs less per month to run than an electric one, because natural gas costs less per unit of heat than electricity. Fixr's 40-gallon water heater guide lists operating costs of $300 to $450 a year for gas and $550 to $700 a year for an electric tank. Your rates and habits change those figures.

You can check your own numbers. Look at your PG&E gas rate per therm and your SMUD electric rate per kilowatt-hour. A tankless gas heater at 0.9 efficiency turns most gas into heat. A tankless electric unit is nearly 100 percent efficient, but electricity costs more per unit of heat. A heat pump water heater is a third option that uses much less electricity than a plain electric unit. See how heat pump water heaters price out for that.

The US Department of Energy points out that tankless units avoid the standby heat loss of a tank, and that they can last up to 20 years against 10 to 15 for a storage tank. Savings come from not heating a full tank all day, so lower hot water use means a bigger gain.

What does a 50-gallon tankless water heater cost?

There is no such thing as a 50-gallon tankless heater, because tankless units store no water. People mean a tankless unit sized to replace a 50-gallon tank, and a typical family needs a unit rated around 7 to 9 gallons per minute. Such a unit is priced as a whole-house tankless heater, at $2,100 to $4,000 installed according to This Old House.

To size a unit, add up the fixtures running at once. A shower uses about 2 gallons per minute, a kitchen faucet about 1.5, and a washing machine about 2. Two showers and a dishwasher running together need around 6 gallons per minute. Cold incoming water temperature matters too. Sacramento groundwater and surface water run cooler in winter, so a unit rated for a given flow at a 70-degree rise delivers less in January than in August. Ask the plumber to size the unit for your winter temperature. For the other side of this choice, see the cost of a tank water heater replacement and the tank versus tankless comparison.

What to do next

Start by checking your gas meter, your panel size and where the current heater sits, then get two or three written quotes. Photos of the heater, the gas meter and the electrical panel help a plumber give a closer price before the visit. Write down how many bathrooms you have and how many people shower in the morning.

Ask each plumber to price the same unit size, and to list the gas line, vent, drain, permit and removal of the old tank as separate lines. To compare your options side by side, get quotes from local specialists.

When to call a plumber business

Call a local plumber before you touch any gas line, vent or panel. Gas, venting and permitted electrical work are regulated in California, and mistakes here can cause gas leaks and carbon monoxide poisoning. A tankless install is not a weekend job. The Contractors State License Board lets you check a license before you hire.

Call quickly if you smell gas, see a leak, or notice that your current heater is rusted at the base. If you smell gas, leave the house, then call PG&E at 1-800-743-5000 from outside. Do not flip switches. A planned swap saves money over an emergency one (more plumbing advice is on the guide home page), so start getting quotes when the heater is about 10 years old. For the first steps and what to expect, see how a job runs.

Questions people ask

How long does cost of on demand water heater take?

Pricing an on demand heater takes one visit and usually a quote within a day or two. The install itself takes 4 to 8 hours for a like-for-like swap. A conversion from a tank, with a new gas line, vent and drain, can take a full day, and a panel upgrade can add a second visit.

What should I ask before I hire someone for cost of on demand water heater?

Ask which unit and flow rate the quote uses, and whether the gas line, vent, condensate drain, permit and old tank removal are included. Ask for the labor warranty in writing and the manufacturer warranty on the heat exchanger. Check their contractor license on the CSLB site before you sign.

Do I need to be home for cost of on demand water heater?

An adult should be home for the visit. The plumber needs access to the old heater, the gas meter and the panel, and you will need to approve any change to the quote. Water goes off for part of the day, and gas goes off while the line is worked on.

Sources used

Last changed